Truth Index+: Office Holder Breakdown

The final post for 2012 will be an office holder breakdown from all PolitiFact rulings through the eve of the 2012 election (November 5, 2012).  The majority (about 53%, or 3,450) of statements put to the Truth-o-Meter at PolitiFact for fact-checking are from those in office:  from the president to senators and representatives, all the way down to local elected officials, such as mayors and city council members.   Here is how the official "pie" is cut:

Click to enlarge

Office holders as a group have consistently held a significantly higher Truth Index (14.7% higher overall) than that of those who were not in office.  For example, they had 43% more statements rated True, and 28% more statements rated True and Mostly True.  In the "subjectively rated" Pants on Fire category, office holders received just 45 percent of the Pants on Fire ratings percentage of those who did not hold office (5.4% versus 12.1%).

The reasons for this difference may be that a large portion of those "not in office" were advocacy groups and PACs, those without a "name" only seeking to promote a cause, and would not lose their voice in losing an election.  Pundits and chain e-mails, mostly in a position of "playing to the choir" could risk making ridiculous statements.

For Democrats versus Republicans, there's no Truth Index comparison for president/vice president: for most of PolitiFact's existence, the office of president has been held by a Democrat.  George W. Bush was only rated once prior to the election of 2008; PolitiFact preferred to concentrate on candidates Obama (168 rulings) and McCain (155 rulings) in 2007 and 2008.  So the chart below does not show any office of president comparison.

Click to enlarge:  Closest party to party Truth Index+ average was governors.

The (raw) Pants on Fire factor, a measure of how much more often a party is assigned a Pants on Fire when a statement rated by PolitiFact is determined False, shows a slight advantage for the Republicans overall and specifically in the categories of both houses of congress, governors and local governments.  The red (Republican) and blue (Democrat) bars are all the same--they all equal a one, with the "fire" bar a measure of how much more that party is assigned the Pants on Fire when they get a False.

Since there was no comparison for president (as I explained above), I decided to compare Obama to Romney for this chart, although Romney, since he was not in office, was not included in the 3,450 rulings.  It does show, however, quite a substantial variance between the two:  Obama has kept a very low percentage (2 percent overall) of Pants on Fire.  It may be a reflection of his very careful speech or maybe something to do with PolitiFact.