Some time ago I posted about what our new Republican Michigan governor and predominately Republican Michigan legislature were doing with pensions, by ending their exemption from Michigan income tax. In calculating whether it was economically feasible for me to retire, that was one of my considerations. Having my pension exempt from the Michigan income tax increased the incentive to retire as it freed up more of my fixed pension income. The Michigan tax is a flat rate on Federal AGI (after a few exemptions) of a little over 4 percent. So it’s not a small sum.
On the surface it looked like the revised Michigan income tax would apply to all pension income, and I had to laugh at my conservative co-pensioners who were just thrilled to have so many Republicans in power in Michigan. The Republicans were basically rewarding their vote by slapping this new tax on them (and giving it to corporations in tax cuts), that would probably have not been enacted under Democrats. Unfortunately (or fortunately for them) most of them came up smelling like a rose on this one. Because the tax is on early retirees for the most part. One in particular, crazy-letter-to-the-editor writing Richard Peasel, staunch Republican, escaped it, because he was born in 1945 (as I recall).
Residents born before 1946 will continue to get the same tax breaks they have now. Public pensions will not be taxed. Income from private pensions, 401(k)s and IRAs will not be taxed on amounts up to $45,120 for single filers and $90,240 for joint filers.
The tax for me would actually affect roughly half my pension income. So I decided, well, I don’t have to live in Michigan anymore. I put my Michigan home up for sale, and right now, I have an offer and am waiting for bank approval. Starting in 2012, when the income tax goes into effect, I (should) be a permanent Florida resident, where there is NO state income tax. So there, Rick Snyder. You lost two Michigan consumers and their multiplier effect, and I hope a lot of other early retirees do the same thing.
When Paul Ryan put out his “Medicare Discount voucher” Budget Plan earlier this year, he had people like Peasel in mind….he let the many boomers who generally vote Republican off the hook so they could get the best of both worlds—not having to pay, yet getting full benefits, then phasing those benefits out some time in the future so future generations are really made to pay for them (that's the implicit or imputed "tax"), starting with me. In other words, he taxed ‘em all (TEA) except those who would most likely vote Republican.




